• 1 Post
  • 128 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: July 2nd, 2023

help-circle



  • I believe I understand the perspectives, but I’m unconvinced that there isn’t asymmetry. It’s one person’s job.

    Like, I’ll whine all day about my job. But I’m under no illusions that I didn’t sign up for it, and I’m extremely cognizant that while it’s a bummer that I have to do my job, I understand that the people I support are having a worse day than I am. I’m not doing anyone a favour, I’m doing my job.



  • See I think this is where in general people in it misunderstand the impact.

    Like, if it’s -40 and your furnace breaks, who is having the worse day, you or the furnace repair man?

    The repair man might be grumbling because they have to do their job, but you’re grumbling because you’re freezing. You both might be grumbling, but by way of impact there is a massive asymmetry in impact.













  • This is an interpretation of what happened. It’s the one that paints America in the most favourable light, for sure.

    Another one is that the “no surrender” mentality was a direct result of the terms of the Potsdam Declaration which demanded “unconditional surrender” from Japan. Japan knew they had lost, they were just hoping to fight for the SPECIFIC surrender condition of the preservation of the Imperial line (aka, let the Emporer still be the Emporer, preserve the family).

    Had the Potsdam Declaration permitted that concession, it very well may have been the case that no nukes would have been necessary.

    Anyways: tough to understand the exact truth of any hypothetical situation. I just think it’s unfortunate that the “The USA HAD to, though” argument is so often repeated without a very full context of the surrounding political realities. It’s a very bite sized explanation, and it paints the USA in a fantastic light. It’s perhaps not a coincidence that it was AT Potsdam that the west hinted to Stalin of the existence of the nuclear bomb.

    What’s the point of building the thing if you can’t prove to the world you have it, and are willing to use it?