Hey! Curious if anyone tried to communicate between GovCloud and Commercial AWS? I am aware they are separated by design. I have a task to try to have a ECS make an api call a private api gateway on GovCloud. Right now the idea is to use private API gateway on GovCloud and a VPC Endpoint on the Commercial side. I don’t think this will work…

I’m certain that this cannot be done without a VPN or having the GovCloud api be public facing, but as I’m not by any means an expert in AWS networking I am curious if anyone has any thoughts?

  • Hexorg@beehaw.orgM
    1·
    1 year ago

    I haven’t worked directly on gov cloud but I’m familiar with its design. The two systems are completely isolated from each other with internet in between. I know you can port forward in AWS so a solution would be to spin up a VPN server in AWS and connect to it from gov cloud.

    • s900mhz@beehaw.orgOP
      1·
      1 year ago

      I appreciate the advice! I’m thinking too that VPN will probably be the way to go.

      • lowleveldata@programming.dev
        1·
        1 year ago

        Obliviously it would depend on the API you need. For example if ECS has to send email via a SMTP server inside the private network (to reach domain mail box or sth). It should be possible to open a public facing (authentication required) API at ECS to return list of emails it wants to send. A service inside the private network can then poll this API (E.g. once per 2 minutes) to retrieve any new emails to be sent. This should work if private -> outbound access -> AWS is allowed.

        • s900mhz@beehaw.orgOP
          1·
          1 year ago

          Yeah they are trying to avoid public facing apis, that’s the major issue here. I don’t think it’s possible. I can get a definitive answer from AWS support.

  • Parade du Grotesque@lemmy.sdf.org
    1·
    1 year ago

    Worked on both AWS and GovCloud for a while, and there was NO communication between the two at the time.

    GovCloud was its own thing, completely separate from regular AWS.

    • s900mhz@beehaw.orgOP
      2·
      1 year ago

      Yeah that’s what I’ve been thinking too and I tried to convey that to the team. However they are still trying to move forward. The only I believe it’s possible is with public endpoints or a VPN. I appreciate the response!

      • Parade du Grotesque@lemmy.sdf.org
        1·
        1 year ago

        Please keep in mind I haven’t done any work on either for a few years now. I would definitely check if something is possible today… But with little hope. AWS support should be able to give you more infos on this connection (or lack thereof).

        • s900mhz@beehaw.orgOP
          2·
          1 year ago

          Thank you, yeah I will talk to support next week. I like to ask questions like this in public so that it could potentially help someone else out in the future